Trump tax bill debate: ‘Donor states’ vs. ‘taker states’
Democrats and blue-state Republicans defend the state and local tax (SALT) deduction and advocate for a higher cap because their states often pay more in taxes than they get back in services.
They distinguish between “donor states” and “taker states” and argue that, as donors, they should be able to fully exempt their regional taxes from their federal tax bill.
“Most of these states … are high tax states that give more to the federal government than they get back in federal services. Most of the red states are taker states, states that get more from the federal government than they actually pay in taxes,” Rep. Tom Suozzi (D-N.Y.) said during a markup of the tax portion of the GOP bill earlier this month.
“It’s really not fair that we are being stuck with this cap on our state and local tax deduction because people are getting taxed on taxes that they’ve already paid,” he said.
Republicans in red states see things dramatically differently.
They argue many residents of blue states are simply living in high-tax areas and shouldn’t get a federal tax reduction for doing so. If they want lower taxes, vote to lower the local taxes or move.
State tax experts say blue states are generally sending in more to the federal government than they are getting out in benefits because they have larger local economies and more higher-income taxpayers.
Republicans are using Congress’s official budget scorer as a whipping boy, as they argue a major package of President Trump’s tax priorities is costless, despite multiple projections placing the plan’s price tag at trillions of dollars over the next decade.
Wednesday, June 4 at 8 a.m. EDT — Washington, D.C.
Join The Hill for a half-day summit featuring titans from Washington and Wall Street, focused on solutions-oriented conversations that will deliver insights into the future of the domestic and global economy, covering everything from tariffs, investing, AI, crypto, taxes and more.
The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a case that involves whether possessing AR-15s is protected by the Second Amendment, but the court’s conservatives are signaling they soon will. Read more
MAGA insider and former Trump White House chief strategist Steve Bannon said Monday that Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), one of Kyiv’s strongest backers in Congress, should be “arrested” if he doesn’t stop traveling overseas and “stirring it up” in Ukraine. Read more
What People Think
Opinions related to business and economic issues submitted to The Hill:
President Trump said Friday in the Oval Office that Harvard will “have to change its ways” after his Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said it would take away the university’s ability to admit foreign students. “Billions of dollars has been paid to Harvard. How ridiculous is that? Billions … Harvard’s…
Social media accounts for the late Rep. Gerry Connolly (D-Va.) urged Democrats to vote for his former chief of staff James Walkinshaw in the party’s upcoming special election, in posts Tuesday. “Early voting starts TODAY in VA-11! This is our first chance to stand up for our workers, our schools,…
In the crisis-filled environment of the Trump presidency, it is difficult to decide which of the many outrages du jour most deserves our attention. However, we cannot afford to ignore the current battle over who will pay the rapidly rising costs of climate-intensified weather disasters. A longstanding legal principle is…